The pitcher went once too often to the well The dodge was tried once too often, and utterly failed The same sentiment is (Atasözü)ial in most European languages
In baseball, the pitcher is the person who throws the ball to the batter, who tries to hit it
A wide-mouthed, deep vessel for holding liquids, with a spout or protruding lip and a handle; a water jug or jar with a large ear or handle